The renegades who first came to international prominence in 1998, when they unleashed BackOrifice, a backdoor exploit for Windows, have suddenly become the most unlikely of heroes.
The Cult of the Dead Cow (cDc) has declared war on Google for collaborating with Chinese censors: “The cDc hereby commands that you print up t-shirts with this graphic and wear them with pride. Join our global campaign against Google’s appeasement policy with China.”
The graphic is a hack of Google’s logo that reads:
cDc has been joined in its crusade by Students for a Free Tibet, which staged anti-Google Valentine’s Day protests that spanned the globe.
China’s censorship has stuck in cDc’s craw for some time. In 2002, cDc contributor Carrie Carolin summed up the problems search engines were encountering with Chinese censors “hijacking outbound requests to visit Google.com and Altavista and replacing them with shoddy Chinese search portals.”
At that time, Altavista countered by creating a variety of domain names to help Chinese surfers circumvent censors. That strategy died when China gained control of its own name space, along with all in-country domain names.
Times have changed since 2002. Today’s search engine geniuses have rationalized their way around the Great Wall blocking them from Chinese wallets.
Rather than bravely standing by those who have lost jobs, been jailed and/or died to defend freedom of information for centuries, the New Age search community seems to have chosen another well-worn path: Collaboration.
After all, this is a money deal. Supporters of this psuedo-Realpolitik view say it’s not the tech firms’ fault they do Bad Things. It’s the Bush administration’s. They need to make more laws.
Interestingly, after decades of somnambulance, the State Department is stirring under the selfsame Bush administration’s prodding. And the House of Representatives is right behind them.
RedState.com reports that, at today’s House International Relations Subcommittee on Global Human Rights meeting, Google tried the ole lipstick the pig gambit:
Many, if not most, of you here know that one of Google’s corporate mantras is “Don’t be evil.” Some critics - and even a few of our friends - think that phrase arrogant, or naive, or both. It’s not. It’s an admonition that reminds us to consider the moral and ethical implications of every single business decision we make.
Google’s right about one thing… “Don’t be evil” isn’t “arrogant, or naive, or both.” It’s self-serving and hypocritical.
While the Cisco, Yahoo, and Microsoft comments weren’t as disgusting on paper, they can be summed up with, “We want the US government to yammer this thing to death. The longer they talk, the more we make. Just don’t pass any laws that keep us from collaborating with jackboots to keep their citizens in bondage.”
Or at least, that’s what it sounds like to us.
Email Battles Backgrounder:

10 comments
Comments feed for this article
February 15th, 2006 at 4:59 pm
trasker
Yahoo!, Google, et al. are the kinds of firms that give capitalism a bad name.
Just because it makes you a buck, doesn’t mean it’s OK.
February 15th, 2006 at 5:19 pm
Frankie
What must it feel like to be a political dissident rotting in the Chinese gulag, knowing that a US company helped put you there. The country you’ve always looked to, just to keep your hopes up. And you can’t help but notice, they did it for a buck. The moral missing links at Yahoo are missing something. I think it’s their humanity. Otherwise, they couldn’t sleep at night.
February 15th, 2006 at 7:21 pm
Montage
It would be hypocritical, to say the least, if the US govt somehow intervened to stop this nasty biz. After all, our elected federal government representatives have conveyed Most Favored Nation status on China every year since 1979. I don’t think Miscrosoft, Yahoo, Google, etc. have to cncerned about any interference from the Washington crowd, unless, of course, there’s a groundswell of support for them to do so.
February 15th, 2006 at 11:25 pm
pzzzofff
wachoo gunna doo wen u lose yahoo?
February 16th, 2006 at 2:43 am
Mike
First: I feel terrible about the situation in China, with dissidents being suppressed by government. However, now that everyone knows that Google is cooperating with the Chinese government’s censorship, dissidents can be more aware in their dealings, and probably have a much LOWER chance of being caught.
Also, this move by Google means that the VAST majority of people in China can now continue to use Google to do all of the things it does, such as search like no other search engine can. While this situation is not perfect, it is for the best. It is not to make a buck, but to provide Google’s excellent service to as many people as possible.
If they had gone against the Chinese governments wishes, you can be sure that NOBODY in China would be able to use Google at all.
February 16th, 2006 at 11:44 am
mick4394
Quote:
Posted on 02/16/2006 @ 02:43:41 CST
If they had gone against the Chinese governments wishes, you can be sure that NOBODY in China would be able to use Google at all.
___________________________________
You are competely missing the point.
Who care’s if the Chinese people have access to Google? I don’t. Certainly not if all they’re getting is what the Chinese government wants shoved down their throats.
Google is not providing superior searching for the Chinese. They’re providing watered down, censored (bordering on) propaganda.
Google is profiting by enabling the type of government that countless great Americans have died trying to destroy for the past century.
February 16th, 2006 at 4:30 pm
Frankie
@Mike: Hey Mike, get a grip. If this isn’t about money, how bout Google, Yahoo and the rest donate all profits to the Chinese people. Maybe to all those poor folks displaced by the Three Gorges Damn project. Then they might have a leg to stand on. But don’t get me wrong. What Google’s doing doesn’t even compare to Yahoo, unless we find out they’re ratting people out too.
February 17th, 2006 at 7:15 pm
Bruce
I live in China. I can bypass everything the Chinese gov’t. throws my way by using proxy servers, ssh tunnels, etc. And if you enter http://www.google.com/intl/en-US/ in your browser here in China, without doing anything else, you are getting the same Google you get in the good old Compromised States of America.
What the Chinese communist gov’t. does to it’s citizens everyday (beating, imprisoning, killing) because they don’t follow the communist party line, is nothing new. The fact that US companies will sell their soul for a buck is nothing new. The fact that Bill Gates is a theif, and got his start stealing computer time from Harvard, is nothing new.
The problem with all of this from the U.S.A. standpoint is that people like Bill Gates own the lawmakers, so they won’t do anything to him….or Google, Yahoo, you name it.
In the U.S.A. it is all about money.
February 20th, 2006 at 9:24 am
slobodan
Bruce! when Bill Gates did not make policy, Washington nearly put him out of business. M$ did not have any option. USA isnt everything of the money until you obtain to the giants like Cisco (great firewall of China) and Search Engines. you say Chinese not same? read a book.
February 20th, 2006 at 4:19 pm
mick4394
Hey Bruce, why don’t you enlighten all of us and tell us where it isn’t “all about the money”?
That comment and your lame little shot at Bill Gates showed all of us where you stand.